What Kosher-NY has to say about it...

Bagel Basket has come a long way since it was Cooper's Bagels on Broadway. Finally settled on Amsterdam, Bagel Basket has come into its own. Although its offerings are pretty basic, the wide variety of bagels are fresh and the prices are competitive. With a great Make-Your-Own-Salad Bar complementing the bagel option, Bagel Basket fits right into the New York Bagel Shop Community. The largest drawback is the size of the venue: seating is extremely minimal (around 6 seats), so prepare to pick-up and go.

(You can be the first reviewer for Bagel Basket.)